Classics Today

Rebuilding ClassicsToday.com for Speed, Simplicity, and Growth
From 2009 to 17,000+ Reviews
Every long-term business partnership has a defining origin story. For FirstTracks Marketing, one of ours began all the way back in 2009.
Over the last 17 years, the Classics Today catalog has grown exponentially. Today, the website hosts well over 17,000 published reviews and continues to expand daily. But as any growing business owner knows, legacy technology eventually reaches a tipping point. To support a database of this scale and turn casual readers into paid subscribers, a major modernization was required. This latest redesign was a long time coming, and we built it to perform, scale, and convert.
Here is a look at how our team collaborated to rebuild ClassicsToday.com for the modern web.
A Fully Modernized Backend: The Block Editor Upgrade
An elegant frontend only works if your editorial team can update the site without pulling their hair out. The old Classics Today backend was a patchwork of legacy page builders, shortcodes, and complex theme settings.

To solve this, we upgraded the entire site to a modern WordPress Full Site Editing (FSE) block theme. The difference for their editorial team has been night and day:
- Live Visual Previews: Rather than navigating a patchwork of page builders, shortcodes, and theme customizer settings, editors can now manage layouts, templates, and site-wide elements like the header and footer directly in the WordPress block editor.
- Real-Time Editing: They see a live visual preview of exactly what visitors will see in real time.
- Custom-Built Blocks: We engineered custom blocks built specifically for the way the Classics Today team actually works.
- Streamlined Management: These include purpose-built blocks for review listings, search filters, and taxonomy browsing, which drastically reduces the daily friction of content management.

Under the Hood: Built for Speed and Scalability
From a pure performance perspective, we completely overhauled the underlying codebase:
- Lean Code: The new theme removes the overhead of legacy scripts and replaces them with lean, purpose-written CSS and JavaScript.
- Smart Rendering: Template rendering relies on native WordPress query architecture rather than plugin-heavy workarounds.
- Database Efficiency: Smart caching keeps frequently requested data readily available without hitting the database repeatedly on every page load.
The result is a fast, clean codebase that loads less on every page request and scales predictably as the review library grows.
Finding the Perfect Note: Reimagining Site Search
With an extensive, ever-growing database, search is the lifeblood of the Classics Today experience. The previous system was overwhelming, confronting users with over a dozen search fields just to get started. We completely modernized and simplified the search experience:
The “Amazon-Style” Experience: We replaced the cluttered search forms on the homepage with a single, prominent search bar that makes it easy to get started without feeling overwhelmed.
- Familiar Sidebar Filtering: Once users reach the results page, additional filters appear in a familiar sidebar layout, allowing them to refine searches in the same way they would on leading e-commerce platforms.
- Flexible Display Options: We added a toggle that lets users switch between List and Grid views based on their personal browsing preferences.
- A Premium Perk for Insider Members: To drive subscription value, we built an exclusive search experience for paid Insider Members. Paid subscribers can access advanced filters to search by artistic ratings, sound quality ratings, Insider-only reviews, and other premium-only content.
This faster, highly personalized search experience has drastically improved usability and keeps classical music enthusiasts deeply engaged with the archive.
Upgrading the Growth Engine: Shifting from Mailchimp to Klaviyo
To accelerate membership subscriptions and solidify their position as the industry authority, Classics Today migrated their email marketing from Mailchimp to Klaviyo. While Mailchimp has been an industry standard for decades, Klaviyo sits on the cutting edge of modern automation and data tracking. Through this migration, Classics Today transitioned from sending generic mass broadcasts to delivering highly targeted, automated digital touchpoints that actively turn casual readers into lifelong subscribers. Here is how the switch unlocked an entirely new level of marketing capability:
Real-Time Behavior Tracking
Instead of relying on basic subscriber lists with delayed activity tracking, Klaviyo monitors links clicked, items viewed, cart additions, and lifetime spending in real time. This rich data allows Classics Today to deliver deeply personalized communications.
Dynamic Audience Segmentation
Rather than manual tagging and static list building, audience groups update dynamically in real time based on actual subscriber actions. For example, the team can automatically target “subscribers who opened three emails in the last 30 days but haven’t purchased a membership yet” without any extra manual work.
Behavior-Driven Marketing Automation
Moving beyond rigid, linear email templates, Klaviyo supports complex, branching automated “flows” triggered by specific user actions. Once configured, sequences like abandoned browse or welcome series run seamlessly in the background to drive engagement and revenue on autopilot.
Predictive Analytics & AI
Instead of relying on standard campaign reporting, forward-thinking AI tools anticipate customer churn risk, predict Next Order Dates, and estimate Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) to directly guide marketing strategy.
A Fair Billing Model
Unlike platforms that charge for every contact in your database (including unsubscribed or bounced emails), Klaviyo only charges for active profiles you can actually message—and advanced automation features aren’t locked behind higher price tiers.
Solutions
- Services Provided
- Search Engine Optimization
- Website Design
- Photography
- Website Development
- Ongoing Website Support
- Technology
- WordPress
- Advanced Custom Fields Pro
- Rank Math
- Gravity Forms